logo
  • Projects
  • Opportunities
  • Organisations
Log inSign up
logo
  • Projects
  • Opportunities
  • Organisations
logoSubscribe to our Newsletter
The Innovation Exchange supports the Sustainable Development Goals
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Disclaimer
  • Acceptable Use Policy
Private Credit Fund for Small Business Loans

Published by

GoodBread

GoodBread

Project start date: 1/1/2024

Private Credit Fund for Small Business Loans

New Paltz, NY, USA

GoodBread’s loan fund delivers attractive returns by financing small business owners—especially women and underrepresented entrepreneurs—driving inclusive economic growth, local job creation, and community wealth.

Design & Implementation

5+ years

$5,000,000.00

Last update: October 05, 2023

OverviewContributors

Challenge

The Context: An Uneven Financial System for Small Business

Small businesses are the backbone of the American economy, generating nearly half of private-sector employment and two-thirds of net new jobs. Yet millions of them are systematically underserved by traditional finance. Community banks continue to consolidate, underwriting models remain heavily dependent on FICO scores and outdated risk proxies, and digital lenders often charge predatory rates that compound vulnerability rather than build resilience.

For many entrepreneurs — especially those operating in rural, minority, and low-income communities — the promise of entrepreneurship is constrained not by lack of effort or opportunity, but by lack of access to fair, timely, and affordable capital. The average small business owner seeking a loan under $100,000 is either declined by banks or offered only high-cost, short-term products. For women, Black, Latino, and immigrant entrepreneurs, the rejection rate is 30–50% higher than peers with similar financial profiles.

These structural barriers are magnified in regions like Upstate New York, where community development capital has not kept pace with need. Outside New York City and Long Island, more than 400,000 small employer firms form the backbone of local economies — restaurants, salons, construction trades, small manufacturers, and retailers. Yet less than 15% report being able to access the full amount of financing they seek. When they can’t, they delay hiring, defer equipment purchases, and often turn to personal credit cards, creating cycles of financial stress that erode business and household stability alike.


The Scale: A Massive and Growing Credit Gap

Nationally, the U.S. Federal Reserve estimates a $40 billion annual shortfall in the small-dollar business credit market — loans under $100,000 that are too small to be profitable for banks yet too large for microfinance programs. In New York State alone, more than two million small businesses account for over 98% of all firms and employ more than half the state’s workforce. Approximately one in three of these firms seek external capital each year, and more than half face denial or partial funding.

In Upstate New York, this translates to tens of thousands of businesses each year unable to secure the financing they need to stabilize or grow. The consequences extend far beyond the owners: every under-financed business represents lost local spending, delayed community investment, and reduced economic mobility. Because traditional underwriting ignores context — like a business’s cash-flow rhythm, owner’s behavioral patterns, or customer loyalty — viable enterprises are regularly misclassified as “high risk.”

The human cost is measurable. A 2024 Federal Reserve Small Business Report found that nearly 40% of employer firms cannot cover two months of expenses without additional financing. Among minority-owned firms, that number rises to over 60%. When small businesses fail, jobs disappear, tax bases shrink, and communities lose the local anchors that create economic and social cohesion.


The Impact: Lost Potential and Compounding Inequity

The failure to underwrite small businesses accurately doesn’t just stifle growth — it widens inequality. The median White entrepreneur holds more than ten times the wealth of the median Black or Latino entrepreneur, a gap that compounds when access to credit is restricted. Each denial of credit at a fair rate represents lost income, uncreated jobs, and diminished community vitality.

For women-owned and minority-owned firms, lack of accessible capital also means limited ability to invest in technology, hire staff, or weather economic shocks. Many rely on personal or family resources, blurring the line between household and business finance. This lack of institutional trust and flexibility perpetuates a cycle where the very entrepreneurs who most need affordable financing are pushed toward extractive products or discouraged from applying altogether.

In addition, the current system’s inefficiencies impose high costs on lenders themselves — underwriting small loans with manual processes can cost banks thousands per application. The result is a structural market failure where supply and demand exist but cannot meet efficiently.


Why the Problem Persists

Traditional credit models were built for a different era — one in which data was scarce and financial institutions operated through centralized branch networks. Those systems assume that the past behavior of large enterprises can predict the future of small ones. But for the majority of today’s small businesses — hybrid workforces, digital storefronts, gig-based income streams — those assumptions no longer hold true.

  • Lenders lack visibility into real-time business performance, and regulatory constraints discourage experimentation with new data sources. Community lenders, CDFIs, and municipal funds, while mission-aligned, often operate with outdated or fragmented technology, making it difficult to scale impact or share insights. As a result, the same business may be over-scrutinized by a bank yet invisible to the institutions meant to serve it.

The persistence of bias — both algorithmic and institutional — also continues to distort outcomes. Credit models built on legacy data disproportionately penalize newer businesses and those without deep credit histories. This is especially true for women, immigrants, and entrepreneurs of color who operate outside traditional banking relationships.


The Opportunity for Change

The convergence of new data infrastructure, behavioral science, and financial technology makes this the moment to rebuild small business lending for the next generation. Real-time bank data, open-finance APIs, and psychometric analytics now allow lenders to see the full picture of an entrepreneur’s financial and operational capacity.

GoodBread exists to bridge this opportunity gap — a technology-first, human-centered lending platform designed to make access to capital faster, fairer, and more contextual. By combining cash-flow analytics with behavioral insights, GoodBread evaluates the whole person behind the business — their management habits, consistency, and growth mindset — not their credit score (we don't have a credit score cutoff).

This approach targets precisely the segment left behind by banks: businesses that can use $5,000 to $100,000 to invest in equipment, marketing, or working capital. Through partnerships with trusted local organizations, GoodBread delivers a “relationship-based” lending experience at scale, using technology to automate underwriting while preserving empathy and trust.

Our model directly addresses the structural inefficiencies in small business credit by:

  • * Reducing cost of origination through automation and data integration

  • * Improving risk assessment through context-aware scoring

  • * Expanding the pool of creditworthy borrowers

  • The Broader Impact: Transforming Access to Capital

By closing the small-dollar credit gap, GoodBread’s work contributes to a more resilient and inclusive economy. When small businesses gain access to fair, right-sized capital:

  1. * Business survival rates increase

  2. * Local employment stabilizes

  3. * Community wealth compounds through reinvestment

In the long term, GoodBread’s data-driven approach will produce a more accurate picture of small business risk nationwide — helping lenders, investors, and policymakers better allocate capital. As our platform scales, the data we generate will inform smarter underwriting practices across the industry, demonstrating that inclusion and performance are not mutually exclusive.

Our ambition is not just to lend differently but to transform how small business credit works — shifting from judgment to understanding, from exclusion to empowerment, and from transactional finance to durable partnership.


In Summary

The challenge GoodBread addresses is both systemic and solvable. Millions of small businesses — particularly those in non-urban, under-banked, and diverse communities — face a persistent and preventable barrier to growth: a credit system that doesn’t understand them. This barrier suppresses local economies, deepens inequality, and wastes entrepreneurial potential on a massive scale.

By integrating technology, behavioral science, and community trust, GoodBread is re-engineering the foundation of small business finance. Our work tackles a $40B market inefficiency that undermines the economic fabric of communities across America — starting with Upstate New York and expanding nationally.

Fair, contextual, and scalable access to capital is not a niche issue — it is central to building an equitable and prosperous economy. GoodBread’s mission is to make that access the norm, not the exception.

Description

The Solution: Technology-Enabled, Human-First Lending

At its core, GoodBread is a technology platform that streamlines the origination, underwriting, decisioning, and servicing of small business loans between $5,000 and $100,000.

We are building multiple components:

  • * Digital Application Platform – a web-based portal where business owners can apply in 10–20 minutes, linking their bank accounts and answering both financial and behavioral questions

  • * Proprietary Behavioral Assessment (BOSS Index) – a short, evidence-based questionnaire that identifies entrepreneurial archetypes and management habits correlated with repayment behavior

  • * Automated Underwriting Engine – built on cash-flow analytics, affordability models, and risk overlays, combining traditional financial metrics with behavioral and contextual data

  • * Partner Dashboard – a co-branded interface for referral and community partners (e.g., chambers, CDFIs, business associations) to invite applicants, track status, and share data insights.

  • * Servicing and Relationship Management Tools – integrated reminders, communication flows, and dashboards to monitor loan performance, repayments, and customer engagement

This system allows GoodBread to reduce the cost of underwriting and servicing small loans while improving predictive accuracy. By automating repetitive steps and embedding human context where it matters most, we can originate loans that are both low-friction and high-trust.


The Approach: A Better Way to See and Serve Entrepreneurs

1. Whole-Person Underwriting

Traditional lenders view applicants through the narrow lens of credit history, collateral, and time in business. GoodBread’s model starts with a broader question: Can this business, led by this person, sustainably repay the loan they need?

Through the BOSS Index, we capture behavioral traits — consistency, organization, optimism, discipline, risk tolerance — that research shows influence business performance and repayment. These insights will augment financial data, not replace it, providing a more complete picture of an entrepreneur’s strengths and challenges.

Behavioral components are being integrated directly into underwriting decisions. For example, an applicant who shows high conscientiousness but limited credit history may qualify for a starter loan, while another with strong cash flow but weaker planning scores may receive nudges for advisory resources alongside their loan.

2. Cash-Flow–Based Affordability

Rather than imposing arbitrary minimums for revenue or years in business, GoodBread evaluates real-time financial capacity. Through secure bank connections, we analyze historical deposits, expense volatility, and seasonality to determine what monthly payment a business can comfortably afford. This model ensures repayment terms are right-sized — supporting sustainability rather than strain.

By focusing on affordability, we open credit access to early-stage or thin-file entrepreneurs without increasing default risk. The algorithm calculates an “affordable payment range,” which guides both approval and loan size, aligning incentives between borrower and lender.

3. Community-Anchored Distribution

GoodBread scales through trusted partner networks — organizations that already serve small business owners but lack lending infrastructure. Examples include local chambers, trade associations, women’s business centers, and entrepreneur support organizations.

Partners refer potential borrowers and, in some cases, share data back on business outcomes. This collaborative model reduces acquisition costs, builds trust with entrepreneurs, and creates a performance data feedback loop that improves underwriting over time.


Methodology: From Application to Loan Management

GoodBread’s lending process follows a consistent, transparent methodology that prioritizes user experience and risk discipline.

Step 1: Awareness and Referral

Entrepreneurs learn about GoodBread through community partners, digital marketing, and direct outreach. Messaging emphasizes opportunity, not desperation — “We help you invest in your growth, not survive the next emergency.”

Step 2: Application and BOSS Index

Applicants complete a short online form covering business basics, purpose of funds, and behavioral assessment. The system automatically verifies identity, collects business documentation, and securely links to bank accounts.

Step 3: Underwriting and Decisioning

Our underwriting engine synthesizes three data streams:

  1. * Financial Data: bank transactions, cash-flow stability, income consistency.

  2. * Behavioral Data: credit history evaluation now, and will weight novel behavioral data as we build confidence through actual loan repayment data.

  3. * Contextual Data: sector, geography, partner source, community benchmarks.

The algorithm calculates a repayment score and affordability band. Decisions are typically issued within 48 hours.

Step 4: Closing and Servicing

Borrowers e-sign agreements, funds are disbursed to their business accounts, and automated repayment begins. Our servicing system includes payment reminders, optional check-ins, and a digital dashboard where borrowers can view status and plan next steps. We emphasize “relationship lending at scale” — using technology to maintain communication and accountability without manual labor.

Step 5: Feedback and Data Loop

Every loan cycle generates a new layer of behavioral-performance data. This feedback continuously refines our underwriting model, enabling dynamic learning and predictive improvement. Over time, the system will get smarter and more inclusive, reducing false negatives and defaults simultaneously.


Why GoodBread’s Approach Is Distinct

  • * Behavioral Science Integration: We are the first U.S. small business lender to incorporate psychometric insights systematically into underwriting.

  • * Data + Empathy Hybrid: Automation enables scale, while contextual understanding preserves dignity and trust.

  • * Platform Flexibility: GoodBread’s modular architecture allows us to white-label or co-brand components (e.g., BOSS Index or underwriting module) with other lenders, expanding reach and sustainability.

  • * Mission + Market Alignment: By pricing loans at sustainable but fair rates (>10<20% APR equivalent), GoodBread can operate profitably while meeting community needs.

This alignment of technology, behavioral insight, and partnership enables us to reach borrowers conventional systems exclude — without compromising credit quality.


Evidence-Based
Our methodology is rooted in a growing body of international and domestic research showing that behavioral and cash-flow analytics outperform traditional credit scores in predicting repayment for micro- and small-business loans. Studies from the World Bank, Innovations for Poverty Action, and behavioral-finance institutions demonstrate that psychometric indicators such as conscientiousness, follow-through, and optimism strongly correlate with repayment rates and business survival.

GoodBread adapts these insights for a U.S. context, particularly in semi-rural and small-city markets where data availability and social capital differ from urban environments. Early pilots have shown strong applicant engagement and repayment performance.

We will continue to test model accuracy against actual outcomes, refining algorithms to reduce bias and improve predictive power. Our approach balances quantitative rigor with qualitative judgment, blending machine learning with human insight.


Scalability and Replicability

GoodBread’s model is intentionally designed for replication. Each core module — the behavioral assessment, underwriting engine, partner interface, and servicing tools — can operate independently or as part of a full lending system. This modularity enables GoodBread to:

  • * Scale geographically across states and partner ecosystems.

  • * Support white-label implementations with community lenders, banks, or CDFIs.

  • * Contribute anonymized data to research on inclusive finance, advancing policy and industry standards.

By 2027, GoodBread expects to manage over $60M in loan capital, serving thousands of small business owners and generating a rich dataset that demonstrates the viability of character-based underwriting at scale.


Impact Methodology

Impact is embedded into GoodBread’s operational framework. We measure success across three dimensions:

  1. * Access: number of entrepreneurs served, approval rates for underrepresented groups, and total capital deployed.

  2. * Sustainability: repayment rates, affordability alignment, and loan renewals indicating business stability.

  3. * Community Reach: geographic distribution, partner engagement, and local economic multipliers.

Each loan represents both financial and social return — a data point in proving that inclusive, human-centered finance can outperform traditional models on both impact and risk metrics.


The Path Forward

Over the next two years, GoodBread will expand lending operations across Upstate New York and into additional markets opportunistically, deepen partnerships with regional economic-development organizations, and continue refining our behavioral and financial scoring models. Simultaneously, we will begin piloting white-label implementations with aligned capital providers, allowing them to leverage our technology and data methodology to reach their own underserved markets.

Our ultimate objective is to redefine how small business creditworthiness is measured and trusted. Through disciplined innovation and rigorous learning, GoodBread aims to transform not just who receives loans, but how the system itself measures worth, potential, and trust.


Summary

GoodBread’s approach combines behavioral science, advanced analytics, and local trust to close the $40B-$250B small-business credit gap. We are proving that fairness and profitability are not opposites — they are interdependent. By building tools that see entrepreneurs more fully, automate wisely, and partner locally, GoodBread is creating a scalable model for a more equitable financial future.

SDGs

Sustainable Cities and CommunitiesReduced InequalitiesIndustry, Innovation and InfrastructureDecent Work and Economic GrowthGender Equality

Industries

K: Financial and insurance activities

Outcomes

Near-Term Outcomes (Year 1–2)

GoodBread will demonstrate that fair, contextual small-business lending can achieve high performance and broad inclusion simultaneously. Over the first two years of deployment, we expect to achieve measurable results across access, financial performance, and system learning.

Access to Capital

  • * 500+ applications processed through the GoodBread platform, with at least 100 loans funded ranging from $5,000–$100,000

  • * 50% or more of borrowers will come from groups traditionally excluded by mainstream finance — women, minority, or first-time borrowers

  • * Loan decisions will be issued within 48 hours on average, compared to weeks and months at traditional banks

Responsible and Sustainable Lending

  • * Maintain a default rate below 7%, demonstrating that behavioral and cash-flow underwriting can produce portfolio quality comparable to banks

  • * Achieve a repayment rate above 93% across all loans, with most borrowers completing on-time or early repayment

  • * At least 25% of borrowers will qualify for a second or larger follow-on loan, proving the model’s ability to grow alongside its customers

Borrower Experience and Engagement

  • * More than 80% of borrowers will report that the GoodBread process was “easy” or “very easy” compared to past credit experiences

  • * 70%+ of borrowers will report feeling “more confident” in managing their business finances after participating

  • * Partner organizations will confirm improved efficiency in referring and tracking applicants, reducing administrative burden by at least 50%


Medium-Term Outcomes (Year 3–5)

By year three, GoodBread will scale lending and partnerships to demonstrate commercial viability and replicability across regions.

Scale and Replication

  • * Expand to 1,000+ loans and $20M+ in capital deployed by mid-2026

  • * Operate active partnerships with 20+ community and economic-development organizations (e.g., chambers, SBDCs, CDFIs)

  • * Integrate at least two white-label or co-branded partnerships with other lenders, licensing GoodBread’s behavioral and underwriting technology

Model Validation

  • * Validate predictive performance of the BOSS Index and other behavioral indicators measured against repayment data, refining the scoring algorithm with actual borrower outcomes

  • * Publish at least one impact report or academic collaboration documenting correlations between behavioral indicators and repayment performance

Economic Impact

  • * Borrowers collectively generate an estimated $10M+ in incremental business revenue and support hundreds of local jobs

  • * Partner organizations strengthen their ecosystems by retaining more viable businesses and demonstrating inclusive lending success


Long-Term Outcomes (Year 5–10)

In the longer term, GoodBread’s outcomes extend beyond loan performance — reshaping how lenders and policymakers view small-business risk and opportunity.

Systemic Change

  • * Establish a nationally recognized model for contextual underwriting, proving that behavioral and cash-flow data can replace FICO-based credit systems

  • * Distribute the model among CDFIs, municipal loan funds, and private lenders, reducing cost and bias in small-loan origination nationwide

  • * Contribute aggregated, anonymized data to policy discussions and open-finance frameworks that promote fair lending and transparency

Inclusive Growth

  • * Serve 5,000+ small business owners and manage $60M+ in active loan capital by 2027, with cumulative economic impact exceeding $150M in revenue growth and reinvestment across local economies

  • * Reduce business failure rates among borrowers by at least 25% compared to regional averages, supporting stronger community resilience

  • * Help close the racial and gender lending gap, providing fair financing for thousands of women and entrepreneurs of color previously denied credit

Investor and Industry Impact

  • * Deliver consistent, market-rate financial returns to investors, demonstrating that inclusion and performance are not mutually exclusive

  • * Show that high-trust, high-efficiency lending can meet both impact and profit goals, paving the way for broader adoption by mission-aligned funds and community banks


Learning and Continuous Improvement

GoodBread’s outcomes are not limited to metrics — they also include learning loops that improve performance and accountability over time.

  • * Every loan contributes new behavioral and financial data that continuously refines the predictive model.

  • * Regular borrower feedback will shape platform design and servicing tools, ensuring a truly human-centered lending experience.


Outcome Alignment with Broader Goals

GoodBread’s expected outcomes align directly with several recognized economic-development and social-impact priorities, including:

  • UN Sustainable Development Goals:

    • SDG 8: Decent Work and Economic Growth

    • SDG 9: Industry, Innovation, and Infrastructure

    • SDG 10: Reduced Inequalities

    • SDG 5: Gender Equality

  • By combining behavioral insight, technology, and community trust, GoodBread directly contributes to inclusive economic recovery and shared prosperity.


Summary

The outcomes of GoodBread’s work are both immediate and transformative. In the near term, we will deliver capital quickly and fairly to hundreds of entrepreneurs, proving that affordability and inclusion can coexist with financial rigor. In the medium term, we will scale a viable model that improves credit access, data quality, and community impact. In the long term, we aim to shift the foundation of small-business finance itself — transforming how lenders measure risk, how entrepreneurs experience borrowing, and how communities build wealth through ownership.

By proving that trust is quantifiable and context matters, GoodBread will redefine what responsible lending looks like in the 21st century — achieving outcomes that are financial, social, and structural in equal measure.